Thursday, January 05, 2006

Index

It seems that sometimes I infringe on copyrights, read my post about "fair use".

Hi everybody!!!

I live in the Netherlands. I visited prostitutes, and thought because prostitution is legal in the Netherlands, everything would be okay. It's not. In fact, there's (probably) lots of human trafficking in the Netherlands. Foreign women are trafficked, but probable also many Dutch women too. Also the working conditions in the brothels are often not good.

This blog is focused on the question of how difficult it is for clients to seperate the "forced" prostitutes from the "voluntary" prostitutes. It is crucial in the fight against the abuses in prostitution that clients are actually aware of these problems, and that they can have the choice to be critical consumers. Unfortunately, the way prostitution is regulated the way it is in the Netherlands, it is impossible to be like that.

Many people believe that because prostitution is legal in the Netherlands, forced prostitution would only occur in the illegal domain. This is not true. As far as I can see most of the human trafficking actually happens in the legal domain.

I'm also trying to map how extensive forced prostitution in the Netherlands really is. I have read numerous reports and they are contradicting each other. Estimates of how many prostitutes are forced range between 0% to 100% of the total number of prostitutes. So this is a big problem. This uncertainty only makes it worse for clients.

Beware that my most recent opinion is that I believe that prostitution can never be regulated and that it would be wise if people didn't visit prostitutes, although I also believe that prostitution should be decriminalized.

Anyway, you can read the first part of my story here:
My story of how I visited prostitutes

and here is the second part:
My story - Part 2

And.... I also wrote a MANIFESTO and a FAQ. Here's the manifesto:
My manifesto!!!

Here's the FAQ (which means Frequently Asked Questions):
FAQ

My goals, methodologies and some conclusions:
Goals, methodology and conclusions

Some vital statistics (I have to emphasise here that there are two separate links under this line, this is not one big link!):
Statistics
Statistics (part 2)

extra statistiscs (gathered from hookers.nl, so under this line are multiple links, this is not one big link!):
Window prostitutes 2005
Window prostitutes 2008
Club prostitutes 2005
Club Prostitutes 2008
Home workers 2008
Home workers 2005
Escort prostitutes 2008
Escort prostitutes 2005
Selected quotes (from hookers.nl)
Extra analyses
More info and selected quotes

Here's a media analysis I've done of hundreds of trafficking cases in the Netherlands:
An analysis of forced prostitution in the Dutch media

Some definitions of human trafficking:
Definitions

Some additional info:
Eastern European prostitutes
Evidence of human trafficking
Thai prostitutes
Latin American prostitutes
African prostitutes
Dutch prostitutes, drugs and labour conditions

I even translated some Dutch articles into English, I hope it will give you a 'positive' image about Dutch prostitution. They are a bit negative though, but I have to stress that they all cover window prostitution. That's where much of the trafficking occurs. But what these articles will show you is that legal prostitution isn't that well regulated at all!! (Anyway, if you're lazy, I want you to skip all the articles except the one by Ruth Hopkins about the slave trade on de Wallen which caused a great stir in the Dutch world of prostitution.)

You will find basically all the remaining posts on my blog (including the translated articles) here:

(and I repeat again: all the separate lines are different links, this not one big link!):

article:'Dutch prostitution policy is bankrupt'
Story of a Dutch pimp
Illuminated from darkness
'I love my job'
A self-confident woman
article:'[Dutch]Police ignores human trafficking'
Slave trade on de Wallen
A top attraction build on oppression
Abuses in prostitution
The prostitution cycle
False promise
Tatjana from Bulgaria
Tom Marfo fights forced prostitution
Loverboys and modern pimps
An interesting report
Strong victims
Running with Atalanta (about Anna Ziverte and Ruth Hopkins)
articles about Tom Marfo and Ruth Hopkins
Threat to switch off city's red lights
Amsterdam makes a clean sweep of de Wallen
Red Thread report
Red Thread report[2]
Red Thread report[3]
surprise!!
surprise - part 2!!!!!
surprise - part 3.....
unsafe sex
history
surprise - part 4
Newsflash!
A negative view
borderline
Sneep
Shared Hope
Thai women in parlours
Burnout
Joran
Highly educated Bulgarian sex workers
Another Turkish gang
Weak!
Zuzana
Forced prostitution in Groningen
Zandpad
Refuse all Romanian girls
Good news
Like a doll
A dark world
Crusader
review: David Farer
review: Sarah Forsyth
review: Jody Peters
review: Sonia Rossi
Montly reports
Blast from the past
The Past
Newsflash - FLASH!!!!
Failed
Moderator
Registration
Zondares
Harassment
Sliven
Positive report
Nurse sex workers
Unsafe sex
All sex is prostitution, all prostitution is oppression
Women don't like sex any more than young boys do
Vulnerable women
Sinned
Fake!!!
Loverboys don't exist
All women like chocolate
Embedding
Column
No link between testosterone and sex
No link between working in prostitution and post traumatic stress
Laura María Agustín embedded
Can't stop
Reset
Column 2
The Dark Side
Pain
Angels and Devils
Eternal Damnation
Is it getting better? At least in Belgium it seems
Review: Linda
Review: John Davies
Happy happy joy!
A new overhaul
Romanian girl
Wallen still a bad place?
Vulnerable Profession
Happy Ho story
Making love as work
Another blast from past
No more
Guilt
Loverboys exist after all
Yes, loverboys exist after all
50/50
A new plan
Land of broken promises
Nigerian forced prostitute on de Wallen
No forced prostitution in the Doubletstraat
Bulgarian prostitutes in north of the Netherlands
A Polish woman wants to work as a prostitute but becomes trapped
A Hungarian case
A Slovakian prostitute
The Hungarian connection
A Polish forced prostitute
A new very bad official report about window prostitution in Amsterdam
A Croatian forced prostitute and a Dutch dominatrix
Struggling
:'-(
:'-|
LJN
The alley
Review: LJN BP7250
:'''-(part two)
It's not working
Clients are nice after all
Bulgarian prostitutes in the Weaze
Baekelandplein
Women for sale
Nino
A forced prostitute from Yugoslavia
A pooierboy from Purmerend
Two other pooierboys from Purmerend
And another pooierboy from Purmerend
A forced prostitute on the Zandpad
Kamtchya
Two forced prostitutes on the Zandpad
Romanian forced prostitutes
Saban and the gang (part 1)
A forced prostitute on the Achterdam and one in Rijswijk
Romanian forced prostitutes in Leeuwarden
Two forced prostitutes on De Wallen
Saban and the gang - part 2
La Revolución
Two Romanian forced prostitutes in Haarlem
The myth of 'being in love'
Interviews with prostitutes - part 1
Interviews with prostitutes - part 2
Interviews with prostitutes - part 3
Okay, let's start all over again
Saban and the gang - part 3
A very exciting story about a voluntary prostitute!
I am becoming a convinced asexual
Bulgarian prostitute in Amsterdam and Rotterdam
An exchange with a woman about female sexuality
What sexuality means to me
Forgive me
An independent prostitute
The quest for the voluntary prostitute has ended
Copy editing
Embedded documentary
Checkmate
Review: Andrea Dworkin's 'Intercourse'
The Dutch sex industry is dying (about a report by the Red Thread)
The Cord (about Toos Heemskerk)
Dina Siegel
The Temple of Love
How many prostitutes are there really?
Estimating the number of forced prostitutes in the Netherlands
BNN documentary about Wallen
Laura Agustín
Attacking Maggie McNeill a.k.a. the Honest Courtesan - part 1
Attacking Maggie McNeill - part 2 : Forced prostitutes really don't dare to speak out
The gang of the miljardair (this is part 3 of my attack against Maggie McNeill)
I am sick
The gang of the miljardair - part 2
Goddess Elena
Saban was really a bad man
The end of the Zandpad
Frits Rouvoet
A prostitute's boyfriend
The boyfriend of a prostitute
The Paradox: why prostitutes have such different opinions about their clients
A conversation with a prostitute
How do clients rate a forced prostitute?
A prostitute on de Wallen and her boyfriend

Okay, I also have some quotes from books about legal prostitution in Nevada, USA. Same problem in those brothels!!! Okay, Nevada is not in the Netherlands, but I'm having a hard time translating all those silly articles which nobody reads in the first place. A bigger blog has more hits. But what's the bottom line is that in the Nevada brothels there are women who work for pimps while the brothel owners know about it and don't stop it.
Brothel, Mustang Ranch and its women
Madam, inside a Nevada Brothel

And I also have a Dutch prostitution-blog:
kris2.punt.nl

7 comments:

Maggie Picard said...

Do you think the short duration of time in service means that these women actually leave the trade? That would mean that exit opportunities are already in place, and women just take a while to discover them.

Or, are they just being moved on to another location, or even killed?

I have read that masny pimps rotate their girls from city to city every few weeks. This is partly because new faces bring in more customers, but also to keep them from forming friendships with people who might help them escape.

In these days of airport security searches, I should think that placing a note in one's pocket, purse or luggage saying, "Help, I am being abducted by a pimp!" - or writing this on the back of a boarding pass - might bring help in short order.

Donkey said...

Yes, many prostitutes leave their pimps very quickly. That's the positive side of all of this. But for those who do not leave their pimp it's because they are scared of him. Many prostitutes are even in love with their pimp. And many illegal foreign prostitutes are afraid they will be deported when they go to the police.

mo said...

Moroccan society and culture has not benefited Holland in any positive way. It’s always the same old exuses. The endless spinning windmill. This Moroccan man that was arrested and in jail telling his story, is not repentant at all it’s all an act. Had he NOT been arrested he would be pimping right now. People like this don’t ever learn. The only way they learn is thru deportation back to there country of origin. I'm an Arab man myself. Why it that I can find a job is, get an education, etc, blend in with your society evey time I travel on holiday to holland? I live in, adapt to my surrounding etc. It is because I am not an animal from some backward village in the Atlas Mountains. I don’t even live in Holland or Europe or even want to. These people that Europe let in through the last 20 or 30 years are the trash or Arab countries. Unfortunately Europe didn’t realize this until it was too late. There’s a saying we have as Arabs. "Never give anyone a chance or opportunity that has had no chance for the last 2000 years" otherwise you open the flood gates of sewage into you societies. As you see now. 1 million Moroccans living in Holland!! My god help you guys you are really screwed. God help your people, culture and daughters.

jehad sydney said...

Mo dont try and talk in behalf of arabs because your just one of those weaklings that gives up his honour and what he believes in to the west or oppressor. If you were a real man with heart you wouldnt let them stand over you and give in to them mate. Wheres the Democracy,Tolerance and Respect of other Races,Cultures and Religions.A person should never have to give up what he believes in to anyone. Why does someone need to give up his Religion and Beliefs to be given a Fair go? tell me that and dont give me that bullshit that our shab is the one that braught pimping in western countries when you I and everybody else knows it was introduced by them not us. Open your mind and smarten up ya kholez

Pooja said...

Hey,
I am a documentary filmmaker doing a documentary about Prostitution in the Netherlands and kinda focusing on victims of trafficing. Do you know any organisations to contact or any place i can get any info????
Any help would be appreciated!
Thanks!
Pooja

Donkey said...

I think the best organization would be COMENSHA (or STV):

see there website:
http://www.mensenhandel.nl/

or their email-address:
info@comensha.nl

Red Thread would be okay:
http://www.rodedraad.nl/
info@rodedraad.nl

louis lammas said...

Hey, I'm a Media Production student in living in England in my final year at University. My final year project is a documentary about prostitution in Amsterdam. I am really interested in what you have writing on your blog, i was wondering whether it would be possible to meet and speak a bit more about your views.
I have a website with a little bit more about i am hopping to film.
www.wix.com/louis1990/thedarklifeofprostitution
Look forward hearing back from you
this is my number
07799600793
lammas_lj@hotmail.com
Thanks